Well I was at Target and I noticed that they had a Cover Girl Smoky Eye set on sale for $4.00 I couldn't pass that up. It included a Dual ended Smoky Shadow Blast eye shadow in Bronze fire, eye liner in brown, and mascara in brown. The eye shadows weren't as bad as I was expecting them to be. They do crease even with a base but they lasted for about 5 hours. The color payoff was OK, the pictures I have won't do it justice because they are very light neutral colors. The eye liner was a very ugly color brown and very wet it took like 2 minutes before it was totally dry. The mascara was good quality mascara but it does clump a little bit and applies rather wet. Over all I at $4.00 this wasn't a bad deal, I believe it said it retailed for $10 something normally I would say pass on the set and just buy a Smoky Shadow Blast eye shadow and the mascara, the eye liner was no good to me.